You are here:Home | Blog | BMW M54 Oil Filter Comparison – Part 2

BMW M54 Oil Filter Comparison – Part 2

Oil filter comparison continued. In part 1 we began our comparison and looked at the Mann oil filter in depth, today we conclude. Please remember that European truck manufacturers use all these companies for their OE Filter production.

Mahle

The caps for this filter are made from plastic, just like the oil filter housing cap itself, while the gasket in the middle is rubber which presses nicely onto the oil filter housing and cap, and it seals well, with no seam inside. Unfortunately, the seam is on the outside – and it’s *not pretty*. It is slightly taller than the Mann oil filter area, but it is shorter than the Mann and Hengst which are equal to each other, what the Mahle lacks in height, it makes up in pleats – it has 75 all up, the most number of pleats out of the three.

Hengst

While the Hengst oil filter shares the same plastic caps as the Mahle, when it comes to printing, it is superior. The actual graphics and texts printed on the oil filter are well printed, you certainly know what you are looking at. The gasket is felt and is a little *rougher* than the Mahle, but for anyone who has ever changed a truck spare part oil filter you know that felt gaskets will get pressed down, this allows them to do their job perfectly – no oil is getting through. While it’s not a lot taller – maybe just a millimetre or two it ranks #1 with 68 pleats, this is a smaller number than Mahle the designers at Hengst have provided an oil filter with perfectly straight pleats. There is a seam on the outside of the filter, but it looks a lot nicer than the seam on the Mahle or Mann oil filter.

The results:

  • Hengst 10
  • Mahle 9
  • Mann 7

When it comes to finding, buying and using a truck spare part such as an oil filter any of these will be fine to use. Of course, you are welcome to buy the cheapest of the three, but if you want an oil filter with a touch more, quality Hengst certainly rates as number one. Mahle comes in second best and while the Mann is ranked lower – mostly as it seems to have been constructed *cheaply* but it is one of the most expensive.

Why pay more for an oil filter that offers a bit less.

Printed on the side of all three boxes is a helpful comparison chart, this comes in very handy if you know your filter size from another brand, you can use the comparison chart to cross-reference it to ensure you get the right oil filter that’s perfect for your vehicle.

Read Also:

Disclaimer: Multispares provides this Blog Page as a service to the industry. All blogs are written by people independent of Multispares. Any views and opinions expressed do not represent the views and opinions of Multispares management, staff, contractors or related parties. The information contained in these blogs should not be relied upon as accurate and Multispares accepts no responsibility for any consequences that may be either directly or indirectly attributed to use of this information.